I watched Noel's game yesterday and have a more mixed reaction. Defensively, he moved well and I had him down for four blocks. Keep in mind that two of these were on what I'd call "Kenner play" blocks, where an out of control ball carrier is moving full speed and is destined to take a wild shot, the kind of play you'd rarely see attempted in an NCAA game. Nevertheless, Noel should not be discredited for this.
Noel was the biggest guy on the floor and frankly, should have been more assertive in the low post. His team went to him there on two possessions early and each time, Noel more or less pushed his shot toward the basket (neither went in) . It was frustrating to watch. Noel did a great job establishing his position in the post and handling the entry pass. But from 5 feet away being guarded by a smaller defender, his shots never had a chance to go in. Later in the first half, Noel executed a pick and roll to perfection, only he shot the ball way too hard and missed the shot. In the second half, he drove from the foul line extended into a wall of two defenders. Knowing he could not take the shot with his right hand without getting it blocked, Noel transferred the ball from his right hand to his left while driving, a very difficult move. The ball semi-circled around the rim before falling out but on this play, it would have been an incredible made basket.
Noel made himself useful by setting high picks for his teammates (particularly for an incoming Gtown freshman named Denver Anglin who can really shoot and was undoubtedly the player of this game). He did have a few buckets finishing a fast break and I believe putting offensive rebounds back in. For Noel to play a meaningful role beyond being a pick setter and 6-10 minute per game replacement, he is going to have to be able to reliably finish in the paint. It's one thing going up against guys your size or larger, but when you are the one with the height advantage, and can get the ball where you want it, and be able to make the move you want to make, you simply have to be able to consistently score from 3-5 feet away from the basket. Noel very much looks like he fits the part. He just has to get over this important hurdle.