Very tough question and would rather be discussing the merits of new big men recruits right now, which we hopefully will be doing soon, in order to give this concept the thought it deserves.
That said, Yinka was probably the freshmen with the most impact in recent decades. Yinka was a very, very dominant college basketball player, which is why he was a lottery pick.
Shawnta was probably the most talented. That's while being nearly a foot shooter than most players.
In terms of raw talent, Pops may be in second and teamed with Mike who was just an important piece
of the team from the get-go.
Yegor, along with Mike, was able to do many things well, and should have been in the NBA. Mike should have been in the NBA longer (he had made the Wizards as a rookie, coaches acknowledge, before an injury sidelined him for a bit. And then he ultimately played his way into the NBA again as a later season addition.
But this is about college basketball. Also Pat Tallent and Clyde Burwell deserve consideration. n
Also throwing an additional combo in this, in addition to Kwame whose biggest heroics came late in the season. Paired with Yinka, Alvin Pearsall was a really talented point guard, who if memory serves, started and played well, especially handling, passing the ball and opportunistic scoring, as a freshman.
ML's freshman recruiting talents (in addition to transfers Tyler, Zeke and Creek,etc) really shone in terms of Pato, KevLar and again, Joe, who was a really solid piece of the team from the getgo. Kethan, if memory again serves, played and blossomed more later in the season.
But right now, leaning toward Shawnta and Yegor in terms of impact, as noted in several other posts.